OPD: Mon–Sat · Fortis Hospital, Sector 62, Noida+91-8910101010
Dr. Ajay KaulCardiac Surgeon · Fortis Noida

Decision guide

How to choose a heart surgeon: the criteria that matter

Reviewed by Dr. Ajay Kaul, M.Ch · Updated October 2026 · 6 min read

The short answer

There is no official ranking of heart surgeons in India, and "best" lists online are usually advertising. What actually predicts a good outcome is checkable: how many of your specific operation the surgeon does, the range of cases they handle, the hospital team and ICU behind them, and whether they explain your risks honestly — including when you might not need surgery at all.

Families searching for "the best heart surgeon in India" or "the No. 1 cardiologist" are really asking something simpler: who can I trust with this operation? Here is how to judge that for yourself.

Cardiologist or cardiac surgeon: who do you need?

A cardiologist diagnoses heart disease and treats it with medicines and catheter procedures such as angiography, stents and pacemakers. An interventional cardiologist specialises in those catheter procedures. A cardiac (cardiothoracic) surgeon performs operations such as bypass surgery, valve repair or replacement, aortic surgery, congenital repairs and heart transplants. Most patients start with a cardiologist; a surgeon becomes involved when an operation may be the better option.

Volume in your specific operation

Experience matters most for the exact procedure you need. Ask how many of that operation the surgeon performs each year — bypass, mitral valve repair, redo surgery or a congenital repair are very different skills. A large lifetime total is reassuring; a steady current volume in your procedure matters more.

Range of cases

Surgeons who regularly handle complex and redo cases are usually well prepared for the unexpected in routine ones. Ask whether they offer options such as valve repair instead of replacement, all-arterial bypass, or minimally invasive access — and when they would advise against them.

The hospital matters as much as the surgeon

Outcomes depend on the whole team: cardiac anaesthesia, the cardiac ICU, perfusion, round-the-clock cover, and the ability to handle emergencies. NABH or JCI accreditation and a dedicated cardiac surgical ICU are reasonable things to check.

Honesty about risk — and about not operating

A trustworthy surgeon gives you your individual risk, not a general success rate, explains the alternatives, and will tell you if medicines or a stent would serve you better. Be cautious of anyone who promises a risk-free operation or pressures you to decide quickly in a non-emergency.

When to see a specialist at all

See a doctor urgently for chest pain at rest, pain with sweating or breathlessness, fainting, or sudden severe breathlessness. Book a cardiology review for chest discomfort on exertion, new breathlessness, palpitations, leg swelling, or a newly found heart murmur.

Common questions

There is no official ranking, and lists online are compiled by agencies or hospitals for marketing. A better question is which surgeon has deep, current experience in your specific operation, at a hospital with a strong cardiac team.

Related procedures

Comparing opinions on your case?

Send your reports for Dr. Kaul's written opinion.

Send your reports on WhatsApp
Dr. Ajay Kaul

Medically reviewed by Dr. Ajay Kaul, M.Ch

Chairman, Cardiac Sciences, Fortis Noida · 38 years · 25,000+ surgeries

Not sure about your diagnosis?

Talk before you decide. Send your reports for a second opinion — from anywhere.

Send reports on WhatsAppCall +91-8910101010
WhatsApp Dr. Kaul’s teamCall